2023
August
25
Friday

Monitor Daily Podcast

August 25, 2023
Loading the player...
Peter Grier
Washington editor

American democracy is in a place it has never been before.

There are some faint parallels: Labor leader Eugene Debs ran for president in 1920 while imprisoned for sedition. President Ulysses S. Grant was arrested for driving his carriage too fast in Washington in 1872 – maybe. The records on that aren’t clear.

But the mug shot seen round the world, showing former President Donald Trump at his booking on 13 felony counts in Georgia on Thursday, is a stark reminder of the nation’s situation. The once and likely future leader of one of the big political parties in the United States will face multiple criminal trials while running to regain the Oval Office.

And the GOP appears ready to rally behind him. Asked at Wednesday’s Republican debate whether they would support Mr. Trump as their candidate even if he is convicted, all but two of the eight candidates onstage raised their hand.

This means the U.S. finds itself in a position more common in younger or less established democracies, where the rule of law can be suspect or up for grabs.

In India, for instance, rule of law measures have declined significantly since Prime Minister Narendra Modi consolidated his power, according to a World Justice Project index. Hungary under Prime Minister Viktor Orbán has seen a similar slide.

Israel has been rocked by waves of public protest about Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s plans to weaken the judiciary.

And all these countries – including the U.S. – are ranked as “flawed democracies” in the latest Democracy Index from The Economist Intelligence Unit.

How much such labels matter is debatable. More certain is that the next 14 months in American politics will be a period like no other in the nation’s history.


You've read  of  free articles. Subscribe to continue.

Today’s stories

And why we wrote them

War’s destructive power affects lives and entire nations. Yet it also paves the way for innovation and rebirth. As Ukrainians plan for the massive reconstruction of their country, they are also discussing the values needed to create a better society.

Jay Janner/Austin American-Statesman/AP
Israel Gomez says goodbye to his son, Ezekiel, in his prekindergarten class on the first day of school in Austin, Texas, Aug.14, 2023. Universal pre-K laws passed recently in other states, including California and Colorado.

Getting all children schooling before kindergarten is generally accepted as a boon to both students’ learning and parents’ livelihood. But what’s the best way to do it? State rollouts are showing that making it work will take patience. 

Podcast

Debate season demand: Sift substance from sound bites

Debates offer evidence of performative skills. Landing a quality zinger can raise one candidate’s stock. Misspeaking can sandbag another’s. But how much do they sway voters? A veteran Washington writer puts the value of these election-season staples in context. 

What Debates Really Mean

Loading the player...

Points of Progress

What's going right

In our roundup of progress worldwide, researchers discover metals that heal themselves, France offers incentives to repair (not throw away) clothes, and vultures help scientists restore big cat populations in Africa.

Suzanne Tenner / Lucasfilm Ltd.
Rosario Dawson stars as Jedi Ahsoka Tano in the “Star Wars” series “Ahsoka,” streaming on Disney+.

The “Star Wars” universe has been built on rebellion, again and again. In “Ahsoka,” the rebellion is in the script – but the show points to a transformation for the series off-screen, too.


The Monitor's View

AP
People queue to cast votes at a polling station in Kwekwe, Zimbabwe, Aug. 23.

When people in a struggling democracy demand free and fair elections, they sometimes feel the wrath of the ruling regime and its security forces. In Zimbabwe, where past elections saw both intimidation and ballot fraud, many decided to try a different approach during the Aug. 23-24 vote for president and Parliament. They displayed a determined stillness.

“For us this is about our right,” Brighton Goko told the Daily Maverick, a South African newspaper, after casting his ballot at 3 a.m. “If it means us sleeping on the queue to cast our votes and have our voice heard, so be it.”

A first-time voter, Mr. Goko was one of many Zimbabweans who spent long hours outside polling stations – even at night – waiting for ballots to arrive. Their persistence shows what can happen when people calmly refuse to consent to fear, cynicism, and dishonesty. Election officials were forced to allow a second day of voting in 40 opposition strongholds to correct the highly suspicious delays.

It may yet take days for the election results to be known. Early counts show a close race between the main opposition candidate, Nelson Chamisa, and President Emmerson Mnangagwa, whose ZANU-PF party has been in power since the nation’s independence in 1980.

Whatever the outcome, Zimbabwe’s election reflects a maturing in the minds of citizens across Africa to cling to democratic values – even where the mechanics of elections remain vulnerable to manipulation. One key to that growth, particularly among younger generations, is what Iranian dissident Ramin Jahanbegloo has called “the seamless convergence of nonviolence and politics” – a recognition, in other words, that democracy at its root demands peaceful means to build and sustain it.

Electoral shenanigans often reveal the weakness of ruling parties. Since 1998, when an opposition coalition first showed then-President Robert Mugabe to be vulnerable at the polls, ZANU-PF has resorted to underhanded electoral tactics familiar in many African countries: manipulated voter rolls and stuffed ballot boxes, stacked security forces outside polling stations, and arbitrary arrests of civil society election monitors.

Those tricks don’t seem to be working as well these days. Participation in Zimbabwe’s election was robust. An Afrobarometer poll prior to the vote showed that 72% of Zimbabweans felt confident that their vote mattered. One reason for their certainty may be a broader trend in Africa. In the past decade, 25 new presidents have come from opposition parties.

For the first time in history, notes Zachariah Mampilly, an expert in nonviolence at the City University of New York, African youth have reason to trust that democracy is a reliable alternative to violence in bringing change. “Africa’s rebellious young people are better understood as harbingers of the continent’s democratic future,” he wrote in Foreign Affairs in 2021. “Behind the scenes, youth protest movements are laying the groundwork for eventual transitions, prioritizing the long, hard work of building support for democracy.”

The ongoing riddle for many African countries is how to move beyond political parties or individual leaders who perpetuate their rule through undemocratic means. Zimbabweans may have an answer. Patient, calm persistence in the pursuit of honest government can bring peaceful change.


A Christian Science Perspective

About this feature

Each weekday, the Monitor includes one clearly labeled religious article offering spiritual insight on contemporary issues, including the news. The publication – in its various forms – is produced for anyone who cares about the progress of the human endeavor around the world and seeks news reported with compassion, intelligence, and an essentially constructive lens. For many, that caring has religious roots. For many, it does not. The Monitor has always embraced both audiences. The Monitor is owned by a church – The First Church of Christ, Scientist, in Boston – whose founder was concerned with both the state of the world and the quality of available news.

God is always speaking to us in peaceful and empowering ways. And listening to those messages opens us to healing.


Viewfinder

Molly Darlington/Reuters
A bee lands on a sunflower at the Sunflower Maze Trail at Great Budworth Ice Cream Farm in Cheshire, England, Aug. 24. The maze is made of some 6,000 sunflowers.
( The illustrations in today’s Monitor Daily are by Karen Norris. )

A look ahead

You’ve come to the end of today’s Daily. We wish you a wonderful weekend. Please come back on Monday, when we look at how the legal defense for former U.S. President Donald Trump is taking shape. 

More issues

2023
August
25
Friday

Give us your feedback

We want to hear, did we miss an angle we should have covered? Should we come back to this topic? Or just give us a rating for this story. We want to hear from you.