2022
May
16
Monday

Monitor Daily Podcast

May 16, 2022
Loading the player...

Of the five mass shootings that jolted the United States this weekend, the one that speaks most ominously about America at the moment was in Buffalo, New York. There, at a supermarket, a white, male 18-year-old allegedly shot 13 people – 11 of them Black. His online writings reportedly suggest “replacement theory” was a reason for killing Black people.

The theory holds that there is a conspiracy to “replace” white people with people of color across the American socioeconomic landscape. It has been cited as inspiration for a number of hate crimes, including those targeting Jews.

That hate is a distorted form of a wider – quieter – fear a significant share of Americans apparently hold.

A May 9 AP-NORC poll found 32% of American adults believe that some people are trying to replace native-born Americans with immigrants for electoral gains. About the same amount express concern that an increase in immigration is leading to native-born Americans losing economic, political, and cultural influence. These beliefs are at the root of replacement theory.

The Buffalo shooting is an atrocity; the wider fear behind it demands patient deconstructing.

Yascha Mounk, the political philosopher and founder of the online publication Persuasion, says the idea that America will be a “majority minority” nation by 2045 is dangerously leveraged as triumphalism on the left and panic on the right. “The left is saying, ‘these rising groups will … dominate politics and culture and all of the problems of America will be solved.’ On the right, they’re thinking, ‘… it’s going to eclipse us. And we’re never going to win.’”

The real world is more complicated than that. Even within the same race, the diversity of thought and identity is enormous.

As Mr. Mounk concludes: “When you’re talking about the majority-minority America, a lot of this is going to be mixed-race Americans; or Hispanics, many of whom actually in key ways think of themselves as white; or people who are going to have spouses or other close relatives who are white. And so this idea that you can understand American society as these two monolithic blocks of whites and people of color – and that is the fundamental dividing line in America – thankfully, is not true.”


You've read  of  free articles. Subscribe to continue.

Today’s stories

And why we wrote them

Amanda Andrade-Rhoades/AP
Abortion-rights demonstrators rally on May 14, 2022, near the Washington Monument in Washington. Protests opposing the possible overturning of Roe v. Wade took place in hundreds of cities across the United States that day.

It may seem like a paradox, but many of the women who turned out for abortion-rights protests this past weekend were beyond their childbearing years. One distinction: Some have memories of a pre-Roe America.

An unusual primary battle between the sitting governor and his lieutenant reflects national divisions within the Republican Party – over conservatism and extremism and, once again, Donald Trump. 

Russia’s war in Ukraine isn’t just on the battlefield. It’s online, too. But experts have been surprised that Russia’s disinformation strategies are as unsophisticated as their real-life ones.

Points of Progress

What's going right

Our progress roundup includes a look at innocence. Unfortunately, not being at fault doesn’t guarantee justice, but a national record of exonerations is one step toward avoiding wrongful convictions in the U.S. In the U.K., not needing to declare fault in petitions to divorce is allowing for more harmonious proceedings.


The Monitor's View

AP
People march to the scene of a shooting at a supermarket in Buffalo, N.Y., May 15.

Mass tragedies often bring a community closer together, as Buffalo, New York, discovered May 14 after the killing of 10 people at a neighborhood store. Crowds gathered in prayer vigils, many singing “Amazing Grace,” near the Tops Friendly Market. Muslim and Jewish leaders gave support to the Black community, the target of a young white man’s violent, racist rage. Those affected were offered free meals along with free funeral services and free grief counseling.

“You can see how vibrant our community is,” local activist Tyrell Ford told Reuters, in citing the acts of kindness aimed at helping people transcend the crisis.

Yet amid the trauma and the calls for action against online hate and gun access, some leaders in Buffalo viewed the public’s response as the start of a better, stronger community.

“We will not be defined by this incident,” Mark Poloncarz, executive for Erie County, which includes Buffalo, told NPR. “We will be defined by how we rally around the families who’ve lost loved ones and to assist others who are in pain as a result of this traumatic experience.”

The city, he added, can be defined by “how we recover.”

That lesson fits the responses in many other places struck by mass killing and that have sought renewal alongside resilience.

After a mass shooting last year at Oxford High School in Michigan, for example, the executive for the local county, Dave Coulter, told The Macomb Daily: “The Oxford community may be destined to be remembered for this tragedy, but it doesn’t have to be defined by it. Let our legacy be the strength we showed in meeting this challenge and the resolve we have to make sure it never happens again.”

Scholars have long studied how tragedy-hit communities – from New Orleans after Hurricane Katrina to Newtown, Connecticut after the Sandy Hook school shooting – can achieve “crisis renewal.” According to a 2012 article in the Review of European Studies by three American academics, “In communities, a common vision and a focus on healing and higher values appeared to be key components to community revival and potentially renewal.”

In other words, each community, based on its unique heritage, can find its way to a renewed identity. For Buffalo, that may mean a new focus on uplifting the city’s Black community. After the shooting, for example, many leaders called for financial support of Black-owned businesses. That will be one more opportunity to turn a tragic event into a renewing experience.


A Christian Science Perspective

About this feature

Each weekday, the Monitor includes one clearly labeled religious article offering spiritual insight on contemporary issues, including the news. The publication – in its various forms – is produced for anyone who cares about the progress of the human endeavor around the world and seeks news reported with compassion, intelligence, and an essentially constructive lens. For many, that caring has religious roots. For many, it does not. The Monitor has always embraced both audiences. The Monitor is owned by a church – The First Church of Christ, Scientist, in Boston – whose founder was concerned with both the state of the world and the quality of available news.

When hate crimes or other animosity-fueled tragedies occur, it may seem that hatred is more powerful than love. But have you ever thought about Love as a law?


A message of love

Jose Luis Gonzalez/Reuters
The moon is seen during a lunar eclipse in Tinum, Mexico, May 15, 2022.
( The illustrations in today’s Monitor Daily are by Jacob Turcotte. )

A look ahead

Thanks for starting your week with us. Come back tomorrow for a look at debates within China’s Communist Party and some recommendations from Monitor book reviewers for your next read. 

More issues

2022
May
16
Monday

Give us your feedback

We want to hear, did we miss an angle we should have covered? Should we come back to this topic? Or just give us a rating for this story. We want to hear from you.