2022
February
01
Tuesday

Monitor Daily Podcast

February 01, 2022
Loading the player...
April Austin
Weekly Deputy Editor, Books Editor

What is lost when a school board decides to exclude a book from the curriculum? 

The decision of the McMinn County School Board in Tennessee to remove Art Spiegelman’s graphic novel “Maus” from its eighth grade curriculum roused a storm of criticism. 

The groundbreaking work tells the true story of Mr. Spiegelman’s father’s struggle to survive the Holocaust, and the effects on his family later. It remains the only graphic novel to win the Pulitzer Prize.

In Tennessee, people are coming together to oppose the ban and get the book into more hands. In McMinn County, a church is hosting a “Maus” book discussion. Fifteen miles away in Knoxville, comic store owner Richard Davis launched a GoFundMe campaign to buy copies of “Maus” and give them to students. Heather Green, who teaches high school English in Knoxville, is supplying a parents’ reading guide to accompany the free books.   

Ms. Green, who taught “Maus” for six years, says in a phone interview that what would be lost to students is an “accessible Holocaust story,” and one that demonstrates how trauma persists into the present day. “What I value most about ‘Maus’ is ... it shows that people don’t just walk out of a concentration camp and go back to living their lives,” she says. 

Ms. Green argues that students are capable of handling more mature books than their parents may realize. Students in her school are already experiencing adversity, from domestic violence to food scarcity. “They need the safe space of a classroom to process difficult topics,” she says. 

Last May, Tennessee’s governor signed a law that would withhold funds from schools that teach concepts that the Republican-led legislature says are part of critical race theory, or that cause students “discomfort, guilt, anguish.” Ms. Green says the new law has had a chilling effect. “We have been told to teach the new curriculum with 100% fidelity to avoid any parent complaints or lawsuits,” she says. 

But she remains convinced that teachers can help parents see the value of difficult books. “When we partner with parents and help them also become an educator for their child, the child has an exponential potential to grow as a reader – and as a person.”


You've read  of  free articles. Subscribe to continue.

Today’s stories

And why we wrote them

Scott Peterson/Getty Images/The Christian Science Monitor
Taliban fighters check vehicles and passengers at a security checkpoint on the road to Wardak province, at the western gate of Kabul, Afghanistan, Jan. 14, 2022. The presence of armed Taliban at checkpoints and on city streets creates an intimidating environment for the enemies of the new Afghanistan state.

How do the Taliban’s foes still trapped in Afghanistan survive? Our reporter spoke to Afghans living in sheltered anonymity, protecting their physical selves, and the people they once were.

AP/File
Soviet Communist Party leader Leonid Brezhnev (left) and U.S. President Richard Nixon walk through the grounds of Mr. Brezhnev’s dacha on the Black Sea in Yalta, June 30, 1974. Today’s Ukraine crisis has echoes of the Cold War and Soviet ambitions.

How do you meet the challenge of a Cold War crisis 30 years after its official end? That’s one of the questions facing the U.S. and its allies as Russian troops mass along the Ukraine border.

The debate over vaccine mandates for indoor spaces is particularly black and white: Citizens are literally either in or out. Part of what’s fueling the division is a lack of clarity about what exactly local leaders are trying to accomplish.

A rise in attacks against Christians across India raises serious questions about the country’s secular promise. 

Television

Liliane Lathan/Courtesy of ABC
Students gather in a scene from the upcoming “Gifted Program” episode of ABC’s “Abbott Elementary.” The sitcom was created by Quinta Brunson (center), who plays the lead role of second grade teacher Janine Teagues. Brunson grew up in Philadelphia, where the show is set, and is the daughter of a teacher.

Debuting a comedy about a school right now could be fraught. But “Abbott Elementary” has caught the attention of viewers and educators who are drawn to the messages at the sitcom’s heart.


The Monitor's View

AP
Supreme Court Justice Stephen Breyer announces his retirement at the White House Jan. 27 as President Joe Biden looks on.

American democracy has enjoyed long periods of lawmakers in Washington being bound by a shared norm: Each party understood that tactics it used while in the majority would be used by the other when power changed hands. Recent decades of rising polarization, however, have eroded that stabilizing restraint and, along with it, much civic regard for minority interests. A continuous cycle of escalation, Brookings Institution scholar Benjamin Wittes told a federal panel last year, has given each party “a significant incentive to violate the current norms when it has the chance.”

Could the coming Senate consideration of a Supreme Court nominee to replace retiring Justice Stephen Breyer alter this slide – or perhaps rekindle some political warmth on Capitol Hill?

Given recent precedents of unrestrained battles in filling a vacancy on the court, that idea may seem far-fetched. Lawmakers, and special interest groups behind them, are squaring off as President Joe Biden searches for a candidate to nominate in coming weeks.

The Senate’s voting trend in past confirmations has shown a steady decline in cross-party support for nominees. In 1994 Justice Breyer received 87 votes in a 100-seat Senate. The last justice to join the court, Amy Coney Barrett, was confirmed in 2020 without a single Democratic vote. That difference reflects how politicized Supreme Court confirmations have become.

Yet conditions favor a thaw. The last three openings represented opportunities to shift the ideological balance of the court. Not this time. Justice Breyer has reliably sided with the liberal bloc, and his replacement likely will too. Democrats control the White House as well as the Senate Judiciary Committee. Other factors may help restore civility as well. Mr. Biden chaired that committee for eight years. He has deep ties with many senators and respect for the institution’s gentler deliberative norms.

Perhaps most importantly, many Americans are tired of scorched-earth politics. A report by the organization Public Agenda found last fall that 8 in 10 Americans thought partisan hostility was a “serious problem.” At the same time, roughly 75% of those surveyed agreed that different political viewpoints should be accommodated and that they could learn by talking with people with whom they disagreed.

That desire for civility and listening can be a powerful influence on political behavior. As Justice Breyer noted in a conversation at the Edward M. Kennedy Institute for the U.S. Senate in 2020, senators at a confirmation hearing “by and large will ask the questions that they think their constituents want asked.”

To a large extent, the deepening hostility in Supreme Court confirmations reflects lasting grievances that both parties harbor over what they see as personal attacks against nominees from across the aisle. Breaking that cycle requires small gestures and sustained effort.

Mr. Biden has promised to nominate a Black woman. In a “Face the Nation” interview, Lindsey Graham, the Republican senator from South Carolina who chaired three contentious confirmations during the Trump administration, called one potential Biden nominee from his state “one of the most decent people I’ve ever met.” His comment surely reflects his own political considerations. It would be politically risky for him to oppose a widely admired jurist with strong support among his own constituents. But it is worth not dismissing what he said.

That kind of acknowledgment across the aisle is rare in Washington these days – and a kernel of hope that political patterns, however entrenched and embittered, can be reset.


A Christian Science Perspective

About this feature

Each weekday, the Monitor includes one clearly labeled religious article offering spiritual insight on contemporary issues, including the news. The publication – in its various forms – is produced for anyone who cares about the progress of the human endeavor around the world and seeks news reported with compassion, intelligence, and an essentially constructive lens. For many, that caring has religious roots. For many, it does not. The Monitor has always embraced both audiences. The Monitor is owned by a church – The First Church of Christ, Scientist, in Boston – whose founder was concerned with both the state of the world and the quality of available news.

Going higher in our love and respect for each other, and in our understanding of God, lifts us to see boundless possibilities for healing progress in the face of a contagion.


A message of love

Dita Alangkara/AP
A woman lights a candle during Lunar New Year celebrations at the Hok Lay Kiong temple in Bekasi, Indonesia, on Feb. 1, 2022. The celebration marks the Year of the Tiger in the Chinese Zodiac calendar.
( The illustrations in today’s Monitor Daily are by Jacob Turcotte and Karen Norris/staff. )

A look ahead

Thanks for joining us. Come back tomorrow for a story about a calligrapher in Amman who collects and displays handmade signs with intricate Arabic script. The signs are historical records, freeze frames of a lost Jordan.

More issues

2022
February
01
Tuesday

Give us your feedback

We want to hear, did we miss an angle we should have covered? Should we come back to this topic? Or just give us a rating for this story. We want to hear from you.