2018
July
19
Thursday

Monitor Daily Podcast

July 19, 2018
Loading the player...
Noelle Swan
Weekly Editor

Jane Goodall probably isn’t the first person you’d expect to apply to shoot a Yellowstone grizzly. The famed anthropologist is one of thousands who have applied for one of the first grizzly bear hunting permits issued in Wyoming in 44 years. But if awarded one of the 22 permits being issued by the Wyoming Game and Fish Department, Dr. Goodall won’t be heading into Yellowstone National Park in search of a trophy. She’ll be on a quest for a photograph.

Goodall is perhaps the most prominent member of an impromptu movement to “Shoot ’em with a camera, not a gun.” The movement was hatched by a small cadre of 19 concerned citizens, 16 of them women, Todd Wilkinson reports for National Geographic. Frustrated by the unanimous decision in May to open up grizzly bears to limited hunting, these wildlife enthusiasts crafted a plan to use the system to protect the park’s beloved (from a safe distance) bears.

“We want to show that the worth of an animal is not measured by how much you can collect from killing it,” Jackson Hole conservationist Lisa Robertson told Mr. Wilkinson.

Wilkinson, a seasoned environmental journalist, has previously chronicled the saga of the Yellowstone grizzly, including the now iconic mama bear known as “399,” for the Monitor.

“These bears have alighted imaginations,” he wrote, “debunked anachronistic myths, charmed their way into our own sense of place, and given us a better perspective on the value of rare species in a crowded human world.”

Now onto our five stories for today, exploring the loyalty of US veterans, the welcoming spirit of Israel's kibbutzniks, and the sense of fulfillment that comes from volunteering for science.


You've read  of  free articles. Subscribe to continue.

Today’s stories

And why we wrote them

Ben Margot/AP
The container ship Maersk Emerald is unloaded at the Port of Oakland (Calif.) Thursday, July 12, 2018. President Trump is offering assurances that the US will 'ultimately' work out a 'pretty nasty trade battle' with China.

For a seemingly dry subject, trade policy seems to resonate with Americans. Perhaps competitive disadvantage is intuitive. The idea of a trade war instills fears, but unfair practices breed resentment.

Those who have put their lives on the line to protect US national security have a unique perspective on the commander in chief’s role and responsibility to the country.

A government plan to expel thousands of African refugees elicited an emotional response from many Israeli Jews – and the idea that kibbutz members could host at-risk families.

Melanie Stetson Freeman/Staff
Sylvia Pollock (from l.), Claudia Gilmore, and Lee Pollock traveled from their homes in Maine to Wallis Sands State Beach in Rye, N.H., to survey the contour of the beach on July 13, 2018. These citizen scientists monitor changes in the beach throughout the year as part of the Coastal Research Volunteers program. Scientists and researchers use the data to make decisions about beach management.

The push to find productive outlets for political dissatisfaction has spread to the environmentally inclined. Frustrated by the politicization of environmental policy, citizen scientists are taking action.

Ginnette Riquelme
Lucio Usobiaga, co-founder of Yolcan, poses in Xochimilco in southern Mexico City.

Sometimes the way forward comes from looking to the past. In Mexico City, one man is helping to preserve a network of floating islands by restoring ancient agricultural practices.


The Monitor's View

Reuters
Satish Bhaykre, who was beaten by a mob due to a fake WhatsApp text, poses inside his house on the outskirts of Nagpur, India, June 23.

The world’s biggest social media network is thinking rather small these days.

On July 18, Facebook announced that it will start removing misinformation on its digital platforms that could spark violence. While the goal is global, the company will act on what it hopes are local community standards, relying on “local context and local partners” to help it in making decisions to ban language and images that might incite physical harm.

The move comes after India accused Facebook of allowing rumors about the kidnapping of children to circulate on its messaging service WhatsApp. The allegations led to the mob killing of several innocent people. Similar violence in Sri Lanka and Myanmar has also been attributed to false information on Facebook platforms. In many countries, rules about the wrong kind of speech are similar to a legal norm in the United States that people cannot yell “fire!” in a crowded theater. Certain rights such as free speech are not protected if they are abused to cause harm. 

Like other social media companies, Facebook is already trying to meet new privacy standards imposed by the European Union and to regulate content under a new German online hate speech law. It is also providing more transparency about political ads that run on its site. And it is working with local fact-checking organizations to better filter out fake news.

Last April, Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg admitted that the company faces a dilemma because, while it is based in the US, where universal ideals are largely understood, 90 percent of its 2 billion users live elsewhere, with different social norms and different cultures. “It’s not clear to me that our current situation of how we define community standards is going to be effective for articulating that around the world,” he told Congress.

Facebook is now on a search to find those local norms, either informal or written in law, that will then be used to restrain local content in hopes of keeping the peace in particular societies. At the same time, Facebook also sees its platforms as an opportunity to create a global community with shared values. For example, it imposes a general ban on certain types of expression, such as nudity.

In a 2017 book, Canadian scholar Michael Ignatieff tried to find a balance between universal ideals and what he called “ordinary virtues,” or the moral operating system of local communities. Such virtues are seen not as an obligation within a society but as a “gift,” negotiated between individuals, one at a time and in the spirit of reciprocity and solidarity. He questions whether the language of rights has “reached into ... the common practices of trust and tolerance, forgiveness and reconciliation that are the essence of private moral behavior.”

What is noteworthy, writes Dr. Ignatieff based on his research in several countries, is the common desire for moral order, or a framework of expectations that allows life to be meaningful.

His work builds on that of the late Harvard University moral philosopher Lawrence Kohlberg, whose research on young children discovered an innate ability of humans to rise up to higher stages of moral reasoning. His work also discovered that individuals at those higher stages can influence those at lower stages through democratic discussion on moral dilemmas. As people’s thinking on issues is improved, they develop a “commonality’’ on right and wrong.

The ordinary virtues of a local community can eventually become universal if people feel both safe and free to communicate with others. Facebook, along with Twitter, Google, and other social media giants, is venturing down this long road. The more these companies honor local virtues, the more they can help define global ethics.


A Christian Science Perspective

About this feature

Each weekday, the Monitor includes one clearly labeled religious article offering spiritual insight on contemporary issues, including the news. The publication – in its various forms – is produced for anyone who cares about the progress of the human endeavor around the world and seeks news reported with compassion, intelligence, and an essentially constructive lens. For many, that caring has religious roots. For many, it does not. The Monitor has always embraced both audiences. The Monitor is owned by a church – The First Church of Christ, Scientist, in Boston – whose founder was concerned with both the state of the world and the quality of available news.

A backpacking trip brought today’s contributor to a stunningly beautiful clear blue mountain lake, but even more awesome were the new views of God that she experienced during that challenging hike in the mountains.


A message of love

Jacqueline Larma/AP
Lisa Scheller (in blue dress) takes a selfie with Jill Schwartz before the grand opening of Hope and Coffee Thursday in Tamaqua, Pa. The new cafe offers people recovering from opioid addiction a fresh start. People in recovery renovated the 1865 Victorian home and built the coffee bar. They also supply the beans and serve as managers and baristas. Dismayed at what the opioid epidemic was doing to her hometown, Ms. Scheller, a CEO who has been sober for 35 years, pledged $300,000 to get the nonprofit up and running.
( The illustrations in today’s Monitor Daily are by Karen Norris. )

A look ahead

Thanks for joining us today. Come back tomorrow, when we'll look at efforts in Colorado to get ahead of wildfire.

More issues

2018
July
19
Thursday

Give us your feedback

We want to hear, did we miss an angle we should have covered? Should we come back to this topic? Or just give us a rating for this story. We want to hear from you.