2023
January
23
Monday

Monitor Daily Podcast

January 23, 2023
Loading the player...

It was the end of a long reporting day for today’s story on coral reefs when Hayley-Jo Carr, a research scientist with the Perry Institute for Marine Science, suggested we make one more stop off the island of New Providence in the Bahamas.

We had been visiting one of her coral nurseries, an ephemeral-looking underwater landscape of shipwrecks and reefs, and there was already a lot for me to absorb. There were scientific details about coral reefs and resilience, new calculations about climate change and its impact on the oceans, the intricacies of marine ecosystems and Caribbean politics.  

Still, I was eager to see the scene she had described for me: an underwater sculpture garden that featured a work called Ocean Atlas, a massive cement representation of a Bahamian girl lifting up the water. 

And sure enough, as I followed the researchers into the glass-clear water, I saw why Ms. Carr had wanted to bring me here.  

When I first started reporting about conservation from southern Africa in the mid-2000s, the environmental community was split between two main philosophies: “fortress conservation,” or the idea that protecting nature means blocking it off from humans, and “community conservation,” the belief that people who live in an ecosystem should decide what happens there. The debate continues between these two basic approaches – we see it play out in gatherings like the recent United Nations biodiversity conference, or the new “30 by 30” call for governments to set aside 30% of the Earth’s surface as protected areas by 2030. 

But Ocean Atlas, I realized, as I dove toward the breathtaking sculpture, reflects another way – one where responsibility and humility meet resilience and cooperation.

The original Atlas of Greek mythology, remember, was holding up the sky as punishment. Ocean Atlas is doing so because she realizes she must. She is part of the ecosystem now – literally, as coral is starting to grow on her surface. She is, in her own unique way, an example of human struggle, of the ocean, and of wholeness and hope.


You've read  of  free articles. Subscribe to continue.

Today’s stories

And why we wrote them

Monterey Park, California, has overcome division and tragedy before, residents say. After Saturday’s mass shooting, they are resolved to rely on one another to do so again.

Ukraine sees the hope of rolling back Russia’s land grab, with help from NATO vehicles, firepower, and training. But the arrival of sought-after Western tanks remains uncertain.

A deeper look

Reinhard Dirscherl/ullstein bild/Getty Images/File
A scuba diver explores a coral reef near Grand Bahama island in the Bahamas. Scientists are trying to replicate resilient “super reefs” to slow the decline of one of the ocean’s most important ecosystems.

Scientists, in a shift from the tradition of not meddling in nature, are replicating coral that shows surprising pockets of resilience amid warming oceans.

Patrik Jonsson/The Christian Science Monitor
Stone crab fishermen prepare their crab traps on the docks of St. James City, Florida, which is part of unincorporated Pine Island, on Dec. 6, 2022. It was to be their first return to fishing after Hurricane Ian destroyed much of St. James City, including a local fish house, in late September.

Two Florida islands embody two radically different approaches to Hurricane Ian recovery. They speak to how Florida is evolving and how it can best adapt to the changing climate. 

Difference-maker

Dean Paton
Holly Smith (front) with staff at her nationally acclaimed Cafe Juanita, which sits on Juanita Creek in Washington state. Ms. Smith took responsibility for restoring the creek bed, and spawning salmon returned.

Environmental challenges can seem overwhelming. But singular efforts can have a big impact – as this chef discovered when she revived her tiny portion of a creek.


The Monitor's View

Reuters
A woman stands in front of a General Electric sign during the World Artificial Intelligence Conference in Shanghai, China, last September.

Big and new ideas in scientific research don’t always originate in well-equipped labs or with more money. Sometimes the greatest resource is freedom. To see why, look at the exodus of people – especially creative innovators and entrepreneurs – from Russia and China over the past year.

Russia’s exodus of talent began with Western economic sanctions imposed after the Ukraine invasion, new restrictions on the internet, and later a harsh military draft of young men. Tens of thousands of high-tech workers fled to Israel, Georgia, or Kazakhstan, where they could find opportunities and free expression in safe havens. Those countries welcomed them as potential founts of innovation.

The exodus from China began with a crackdown on its biggest tech companies, especially their founders, as well as a draconian lockdown of cities against COVID-19. Many of the country’s most creative people moved to the United States, Singapore, and Japan to avoid China’s increasing techno-authoritarianism, or a top-down approach to research.

“Now that they have lived free of fear in other countries, they are reluctant to put themselves and their businesses under the thumb of the Chinese Communist Party again,” wrote The New York Times. One founder of a crypto banking startup cited the need to have a say in how government makes rules. “There are many other places [than China] where you can do things,” said Aginny Wang, a co-founder of Flashwire who moved from China to Singapore.

These two waves of talent emigration, both of which may set back each country’s science and technology, are timely reminders about the most basic element for breakthroughs in scientific thought: freedom. They come as yet another study suggests global science has been in a slump in producing “disruptive” discoveries, such as lasers, airplanes, and transistors.

The study, conducted at the University of Minnesota and the University of Arizona, looked at 45 million papers and 3.9 million U.S. patents from 1945 to 2010 to see which research pointed to groundbreaking disruptions in fields from physics to social science. This “disruption index” showed a decline in basic discoveries after World War II and then a leveling since the 1990s. Also noted was an increase in the use of words like “improve” and “enhance” over language such as “make” and “produce.”

As in China and Russia today, many researchers may feel less free to pursue novel and radical ideas. In the West, scholars are publishing research more than ever but in increasingly narrower silos of knowledge. Many spend half their time applying for government grants, which are often given out based on demands for immediate, risk-free results.

“Rather than minting revolutionary ways of thinking, science and technology are increasingly polishing the same conceptual pennies,” writes science commentator Anjana Ahuja in The Financial Times.

The study’s authors say scientific workers can find greater freedom in undirected research and more sabbaticals. Long-shot research begins with short-term liberties to think, explore, make mistakes, and share ideas freely. The best research centers are small in number with high trust and no compulsion for conformity. Or just the opposite of what authoritarian leaders prefer. More freedom may be the greatest disruptor in the world of science seeking disruptive ideas.


A Christian Science Perspective

About this feature

Each weekday, the Monitor includes one clearly labeled religious article offering spiritual insight on contemporary issues, including the news. The publication – in its various forms – is produced for anyone who cares about the progress of the human endeavor around the world and seeks news reported with compassion, intelligence, and an essentially constructive lens. For many, that caring has religious roots. For many, it does not. The Monitor has always embraced both audiences. The Monitor is owned by a church – The First Church of Christ, Scientist, in Boston – whose founder was concerned with both the state of the world and the quality of available news.

When tragedy strikes, we can turn to the comforting truth that God is Life itself and find peace.


A message of love

Sarah Meyssonnier/Reuters
A baker holds a loaf of bread during a demonstration of French bakers to demand governmental aid in the face of soaring energy prices, in Paris on Jan. 23, 2023.
( The illustrations in today’s Monitor Daily are by Karen Norris. )

A look ahead

Thanks for starting off your week with the Monitor. Tuesday, we’ll look at global trade and a “cold war 2.0.” Whatever you call it, how far China and the West drift apart may depend on where concerns about national security and a desire for economic growth reach a new equilibrium.

More issues

2023
January
23
Monday

Give us your feedback

We want to hear, did we miss an angle we should have covered? Should we come back to this topic? Or just give us a rating for this story. We want to hear from you.