2022
November
23
Wednesday

Monitor Daily Podcast

November 23, 2022
Loading the player...

Tomorrow is Thanksgiving Day in the United States, so our first story explores gratitude, including my own gratitude for all those who so generously shared their stories – and for you, my readers. 

But first there’s someone else I’d like to thank: David Clark Scott. He devoted 42 years to the Monitor and had just taken on a new role as cover story editor when he assigned the story to me. But he passed away the day it was due. 

Ever supportive of his writers, Dave did some reporting of his own for the story. We wanted to share his final dispatch with you:

When fifth grade teacher Suzi Winterbottom needs a morale boost, she reaches for a green plastic box she keeps near her desk. Inside are keepsakes and thank-you notes from students that she’s collected over a decade of teaching.

This past spring, an unexpected thank-you note arrived for her at Mary K. Goode Elementary School in Middleborough, Massachusetts. The note was particularly timely because this was a rough year for Mrs. Winterbottom – and many other teachers.

“We went from being heroes during the pandemic to having parents tell us we’re not doing enough to help children make up for lost time,” she observes. Test scores show many students in the U.S. fell behind during the pandemic. Also, their social and communication skills had atrophied. “They’d forget to raise their hands. They’d blurt out answers,” Mrs. Winterbottom says. “It was exhausting.”

But then a letter came from a student who had been in her class six years ago when she taught third grade.

“At the time she was a new kid. Feisty. Too cool for school,” recalls Mrs. Winterbottom. One day, the student was fooling around during a test and knocked over a handmade glass container that had been a gift from Mrs. Winterbottom’s daughter. It shattered on the floor. The girl ignored it. She didn’t clean it up. She didn’t say, “I’m sorry.” Nothing.

The letter was a much-belated note of apology, and a recognition of Mrs. Winterbottom’s kindness during her first year in town. “You were definitely one of my favorite teachers from elementary school,” she wrote.

“It’s these little sparks of gratitude that renew the feeling of why I do this job,” Mrs. Winterbottom says. “It reminds you that the person they may present to you – stubborn, resistant, or just plain uninterested – well, it doesn’t necessarily mean they aren’t recognizing the care that you’re giving to them.”

The letter has found a place in Mrs. Winterbottom’s green box of classroom treasures.


You've read  of  free articles. Subscribe to continue.

Today’s stories

And why we wrote them

A deeper look

Karen Norris/Staff

In the bustle and tumult of daily life, giving thanks can come as an afterthought. For these regular practitioners of gratitude, however, Thanksgiving comes every day.

Pavel Mikheyev/Reuters
A voter casts a ballot at a polling station during presidential elections outside Almaty, Kazakhstan, Nov. 20, 2022. President Kassym-Jomart Tokayev won easily with a 81.3% share of the vote.

Amid Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, Kazakhstan is set to redefine its foreign relations. While Astana cannot sever its ties with Moscow, it now has an opportunity to engage more broadly with the world.

Patterns

Tracing global connections

Qatar stands accused of using the soccer World Cup to launder its poor human rights image. But such “sportswashing” is increasingly ineffectual as potential sporting hosts are judged by ever-higher standards.

Cooking often involves adaptation. Southern cooks evolved recipes for sweet potato pie, while in the North, pumpkin reigned supreme. Now, people are crossing the borders of pie cuisine. 

Essay

Stephanie Zollshan/The Berkshire Eagle/AP/File
Faustina Mahl digs in to her meal at the annual Thanksgiving community dinner in Pittsfield, Massachusetts. The more one savors one’s blessings, the larger they loom.

Conscious gratitude enriches and enlivens everyone who participates in it, as my older sister showed.


The Monitor's View

AP
Ukrainian children and their mothers receive educational support at a facility in Warsaw, Poland, Nov. 9.

Close to 4% of people worldwide live in countries other than where they were born. That represents an unprecedented scale of human movement across borders and continents – enough to make up the fourth-largest country by population if banded together. Here is one migrant story you might not have heard.

In Poland, Turkey, and the Czech Republic, Ukrainians fleeing war have organized weekly events to clean the streets and public parks in the towns that have taken them in. These acts of gratitude are based on a Ukrainian custom of giving time freely to better the community. In some cities, locals have joined in and new friendships have been formed.

“By cleaning up the garbage, we want to say ‘thank you,’” Lena Bondarenko told Gazeta Wyborcza, a newspaper in the Polish town of Poznán. “Even in this symbolic way, we want to show the whole city of Poznán that we are grateful to you. I never imagined you could be so hospitable. My voice breaks.”

The currents of migration have at times stirred unease in societies that fear their norms and identities are being changed. But the arrival of foreigners is also forming eddies of hospitality and gratitude. In the United States, welcoming strangers is at the heart of the annual Thanksgiving holiday. In his Thanksgiving Proclamation of 1795, President George Washington urged his fellow citizens to pray that God would “render this country more and more a safe and propitious asylum for the unfortunate of other countries.”

That ideal was rooted in a conviction, echoed by presidents from then to now, that the nation ought to show gratitude for peace and prosperity through selfless devotion to the welfare of others. Our duty to God, President Theodore Roosevelt wrote in his 1907 Thanksgiving Proclamation, requires “the virtues that tell for gentleness and tenderness, for loving kindness and forbearance, one toward another.”

Gratitude for the skills that migrants bring may be causing a subtle shift in societies with deeply rooted definitions of national identity. In Germany, France, and Britain, according to a 2021 Pew survey, fewer people are insisting on traditional markers of belonging – such as ethnicity, being born in the country, being Christian, or speaking the national language. The study found that citizens are also “more likely to believe that migrants want to adopt [their] customs and ways of life.”

In the U.S., meanwhile, 78% of Americans approved of “allowing up to 100,000” Ukrainian refugees into the country after the Russian invasion. “This is the highest level of U.S. public support for admitting refugees that Gallup has found in its polling on various refugee situations since 1939,” the pollster noted.

For many Christians, this mix of hospitality and gratitude is not an end in itself. Writing to the Corinthians, Paul stated, “All things are for your sakes, that the abundant grace might through the thanksgiving of many redound to the glory of God.” In a world being reshaped by people fleeing their homelands, new bonds of affection are being forged, creating a higher meaning of home as a spiritual belonging.


A Christian Science Perspective

About this feature

Each weekday, the Monitor includes one clearly labeled religious article offering spiritual insight on contemporary issues, including the news. The publication – in its various forms – is produced for anyone who cares about the progress of the human endeavor around the world and seeks news reported with compassion, intelligence, and an essentially constructive lens. For many, that caring has religious roots. For many, it does not. The Monitor has always embraced both audiences. The Monitor is owned by a church – The First Church of Christ, Scientist, in Boston – whose founder was concerned with both the state of the world and the quality of available news.

Sometimes it can seem we’re missing something in our lives. Recognizing that we are all included in God’s abundance brings healing and solutions.


A message of love

Brendan McDermid/Reuters
Travelers navigate through Grand Central Terminal in New York City, as people travel ahead of the Thanksgiving holiday, Nov. 23, 2022.
( The illustrations in today’s Monitor Daily are by Jacob Turcotte and Karen Norris. )

A look ahead

Thanks again for joining us. The Monitor will take a break from publishing tomorrow for Thanksgiving Day. On Friday, watch for an email at our regular time carrying a new episode of our weekly podcast “Why We Wrote This.” Your regular Daily returns Monday with a look at how architects are working to make cities safer for birds. 

More issues

2022
November
23
Wednesday

Give us your feedback

We want to hear, did we miss an angle we should have covered? Should we come back to this topic? Or just give us a rating for this story. We want to hear from you.