2021
January
11
Monday

Monitor Daily Podcast

January 11, 2021
Loading the player...
Clayton Collins
Director of Editorial Innovation

The work of ensuring accountability and consequences, at all levels, for last Wednesday’s insurrection at the U.S. Capitol deepens.

One effort targets the root. Social media platforms have acted to stem deadly disinformation. (See our third story, below.) Now, besides transparency and persistence, what could help restore trust in fact-based news? Maybe a little humanization. 

Some members of the media – called “enemies of the people,” “fake news,” “soft targets,” and worse – are pursuing a vital role, especially in local news. It goes far beyond traditional service journalism. It exhibits the heart of public service. 

Andy Larsen, a Utah reporter, started a holiday help fund with $165.84 that his mother found stashed in his childhood bedroom. He tweeted about his plan to use it to ease families’ strain. Then donors chipped in. He would end up distributing $55,000 to people facing pandemic-depleted holidays, reported The Washington Post

“It was important to me to verify every story,” he says, “and help as many people as possible.”

Having a journalist’s skill set helps. CD Davidson-Hiers, a Florida reporter, kept seeing messages from readers about COVID-19 vaccinations. Her small paper has no dedicated health beat so she offered to run down answers. More than 150 readers took her up on that within days, according to Poynter. She has helped seniors with applications and online forms. She follows up. She reassures.

“There’s a lot of murk to wade through,” she says. But “to have people call me directly now with questions, real questions, this feels like why I got into this profession.”


You've read  of  free articles. Subscribe to continue.

Today’s stories

And why we wrote them

Erin Scott/Reuters
A demonstrator holds a sign reading ‘Impeach’ Jan. 11, days after supporters of President Donald Trump invaded the Capitol in an attempted insurrection. A majority of Americans say they support his removal from office.

What is true unity? As Congress works toward a just response to the Capitol siege, lawmakers say that it’s not something to be achieved by setting accountability aside: our report.

Ann Scott Tyson/The Christian Science Monitor/File
Hong Kong district councilor Fergus Leung, a pro-democracy advocate and Hong Kong University student, meets with constituents near the Kwun Lung public housing estate in western Hong Kong Island in November 2019.

China’s latest Hong Kong crackdown had us revisiting our story about a student elected to local office there last year. We look at why the ground keeps shifting, and what defense of that fragile democracy now requires. 

The Explainer

Responsive moves by social media firms amount to a reboot of internet-based political discourse. One of our editors – a former research attorney – shows why some claims about a slippery slope on censorship are off-base.

A deeper look

Jeff Amy/AP/File
Then-Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos talks with chemistry students during a visit to Forsyth Central High School in Cumming, Georgia, Aug. 25, 2020. During her tenure, Ms. DeVos changed the tenor and direction of discussion about public education.

The outgoing secretary of education was an unusually controversial figure. Our reporter takes a deeper look at what her work revealed, fundamentally, about the debate over public and private roles in American schooling.

Points of Progress

What's going right
Staff

Urban farmers beat gentrification and pandemic, illegal loggers lose their foothold in Kenya, single-use plastic gets targeted in China, and more. Here’s our weekly survey of global gains.


The Monitor's View

AP
An Israeli couple celebrates their Dec. 17 wedding in Dubai, United Arab Emirates, a sign of warming Arab-Israeli relations.

For decades Israel and much of the Arab world have molded perceptions of each other through textbooks for schoolchildren. The books taught students histories that disparage one side or the other and helped entrench conflict in the Middle East. Now, as more Arab leaders find common cause with Israel and take steps to normalize relations with it, some of them may also realize they must mold public opinion in a more favorable way.

A hint of this shift comes from a partial survey of Saudi textbooks for the current academic year. It was conducted by Impact-se, a nongovernmental Israeli organization that tracks how Israelis and Jews are portrayed in Arab curricula. It notes some significant changes. Longtime anti-Semitic tropes have been removed, as have passages condemning gay people, glorifying jihad, and denying the rights of women.

That tracks with trends seen elsewhere in the region. A study of textbooks in the United Arab Emirates found a “dedicated focus” on issues the West does not normally associate with education systems rooted in Islam: civic engagement, critical thinking, pluralism, protection from extremism, equality, and compassionate justice. That study was published in July by scholars at Zayed University in Abu Dhabi, the capital of the UAE, and American University in Dubai. In September, the UAE normalized ties with Israel.

Such attempts to change thinking about Israelis or Western values are up against entrenched views. The latest Arab Opinion Index, a survey conducted in 13 Arab states and released in November, showed that 66% of Arabs think Israel and the United States pose the greatest threat to peace and stability in the region, while only 12% say Iran does. An aggregate of 79% of respondents say the cause of Palestinians under Israeli control concerns all Arabs, and 88% disapprove of recognition of Israel by their home country.

In two of the countries that have moved toward normalizing ties with Israel in recent months, Morocco and Sudan, just 4% and 13% respectively support that diplomatic shift. These findings are consistent with individual national polls.

In Israel, annual budgets and official statistics on class size and student academic performance reveal persistent systemic discrimination. Arab and Jewish students are generally taught in separate schools.

But some important shifts may be unfolding there, too. A small but growing number of schools are sharing resources across ethnic and religious lines and collaborating on projects. In recent years Israel’s Ministry of Education has worked with local groups to increase the number of Arab teachers in Jewish schools.

“Translating peacemaking into our educational systems,” argues Gershon Baskin, founder of the Israel/Palestine Center for Research and Information, in The Jerusalem Post, requires finding “new and positive ways to relate to the ‘Other’ within the region and among us, especially for the young generations of Israelis and Palestinians.”

Societies do not remain static. Perspectives shaped in the service of conflict can be reshaped in the pursuit of peace. If differences and hatred can be taught, so can common humanity and shared interests.

As stereotypes fall in the Middle East, so may tension between Israel and its neighbors. The cost of such progress is not high. It can start with more balanced textbooks and more classroom contacts between Israelis and Palestinians.


A Christian Science Perspective

About this feature

Each weekday, the Monitor includes one clearly labeled religious article offering spiritual insight on contemporary issues, including the news. The publication – in its various forms – is produced for anyone who cares about the progress of the human endeavor around the world and seeks news reported with compassion, intelligence, and an essentially constructive lens. For many, that caring has religious roots. For many, it does not. The Monitor has always embraced both audiences. The Monitor is owned by a church – The First Church of Christ, Scientist, in Boston – whose founder was concerned with both the state of the world and the quality of available news.

Even when disagreement turns hostile, God has given us the courage to stand up for our inherent unity as brothers and sisters in God – which paves the way for resolution and healing.


A message of love

Efrem Lukatsky/AP
A cook is seen making a pizza through a pizzeria window decorated with Christmas ornaments in Kyiv, Ukraine, Jan. 11, 2021. The country of 42 million, which celebrated Christmas on Jan. 7, will be under a new coronavirus lockdown beginning Friday, closing schools, entertainment venues, and restaurant table service until Jan. 25.
( The illustrations in today’s Monitor Daily are by Karen Norris. )

A look ahead

Join us again tomorrow. We’ll be looking at the “idealist” goals of the Biden foreign policy team – global leadership, democracy, human rights – and why some from the “realist” school worry that those could lead to costly interventionism.

As always, find the faster-moving stories that we’re watching on our First Look page

More issues

2021
January
11
Monday

Give us your feedback

We want to hear, did we miss an angle we should have covered? Should we come back to this topic? Or just give us a rating for this story. We want to hear from you.