2019
October
17
Thursday

Monitor Daily Podcast

October 17, 2019
Loading the player...
Mark Sappenfield
Senior global correspondent

Today’s five hand-picked stories look at the history of presidents and the deep state, Israel’s concern about U.S. commitment to the Mideast, a different view of Brexit, the First Commandment in a modern context, and teaching moms to fight terrorism.

But first, in the stories about Democratic Rep. Elijah Cummings of Maryland, who died today, you’ll see one phrase often repeated: “Trump target” or “Trump foil.” Yes, Mr. Cummings and President Donald Trump crossed swords. But what an inadequate picture of the man that is.

At a time when our partisan identities can tend to occlude everything else, Mr. Cummings is a reminder why it’s wise always to start with the “everything else.”

When Baltimore descended into racially charged riots in 2015, Mr. Cummings linked arm-in-arm with residents to walk through the streets singing, “This Little Light of Mine.” A day after freshman Democratic Rep. Rashida Tlaib accused Republican Rep. Mark Meadows of a racist stunt earlier this year, Mr. Cummings had them hugging.

How did he do it? “Human interaction, that’s all,” he said.

Famously, during congressional hearings into the Benghazi crisis in 2015, Mr. Cummings shouted at his Republican colleague, Rep. Trey Gowdy, “Gentleman, yield! You have made several inaccurate statements.”

But Mr. Gowdy held no ill will. “It’s not about politics to him; he says what he believes,” Mr. Gowdy told The Hill newspaper. “And you can tell the ones who are saying it because it was in a memo they got that morning, and you can tell the ones who it’s coming from their soul. And with Mr. Cummings, it’s coming from his soul.”


You've read  of  free articles. Subscribe to continue.

Today’s stories

And why we wrote them

The impeachment inquiry against the president hinges on testimony from people deep in the federal bureaucracy. But that’s not necessarily ominous. All presidents must navigate the ‘deep state.’

Pavel Golovkin/Reuters
Presidents Hassan Rouhani of Iran, on right, Recep Tayyip Erdoğan of Turkey, middle, and Vladimir Putin of Russia gathered at a news conference during their meeting in Ankara, Turkey, Sept. 16, 2019. Their countries all were strengthened by the U.S. withdrawal from northern Syria.

President Donald Trump has cast himself as a staunch friend of Israel, but what Israel wants most is for the U.S. to remain active in the region. Withdrawal from Syria is causing concern.

Here’s a perspective on Brexit you probably haven’t yet heard. Britons living abroad in the European Union are facing new uncertainties. 

The Ten

How people use the Commandments in daily life
Ann Hermes/Staff
Carlos Vila, a practicing Roman Catholic, enjoys a moment at home with the family dog, Charlotte, on Oct. 16, 2019, in Berwyn, Pennsylvania.

Carlos Vila’s religious life is filled with questions. But for him, the First Commandment opens a larger sense of purpose and joy. Part 1 in a series looking at the Ten Commandments through modern lives.

Difference-maker

Courtesy of Women without Borders
Social scientist and activist Edit Schlaffer founded Women without Borders in Vienna in 2001. Her work in crisis zones led to MotherSchools, a curriculum that operates in areas where young people are vulnerable to radicalization.

What if you could actually train mothers to turn their compassion and connection into the first line of defense against terrorism? In Germany and 15 other countries, it’s happening.


The Monitor's View

AP
Actor, comedian, and talkshow host Ellen DeGeneres arrives at the Oct. 6 NFL game between the Green Bay Packers and Dallas Cowboys.

At an early October Dallas Cowboys game, cameras turned to an audience box and showed two unlikely neighbors laughing together: former President George W. Bush and comedian Ellen DeGeneres. The image went viral, and reactions were febrile.

Two camps quickly emerged. One thought the warm pairing of a gay, liberal comedian with a conservative, Republican president represented a moment of much-needed civility. The other side thought it amounted to a betrayal. President Bush, the latter argued, initiated endless wars, responded slowly to Hurricane Katrina, even advocated restricting LGBTQ rights, which would have affected Ms. DeGeneres directly. Two people so at odds politically, they said, should also be at odds socially.

For Ms. DeGeneres on this occasion, those differences didn’t matter. Echoing the golden rule on her talk show two days later, she argued against being kind to only those like-minded in political views. “Just because I don’t agree with someone on everything,” she said, “doesn’t mean that I’m not going to be friends with them.” Mr. Bush, she said, was her friend.

Many called Ms. DeGeneres’ monologue reductive, flip, and pharisaical. Saying Mr. Bush was a friend meant accepting his actions. There are some people, they argued, with whom we shouldn’t be friends.

The debate over Ms. DeGeneres and the former president embodies a larger question in American culture: How do we live with people whose opinions and actions are so different from ours? In a time when differences sometimes feel threatening, do we even interact at all?

Polls show much of the public thinks not, with many saying they’ve stopped talking to someone over political differences (50% for Democrats, 38% for Republicans, and 35% for independents). Activist groups, especially on college campuses, often argue over who even deserves a voice – sometimes turning to violence to suppress others.

A recent experiment suggests this intolerance can end. Organized by academics and consultants, a project called America in One Room gathered a representative sample of 523 voters in Dallas and staged a weekend of lectures and discussions. Participants of both parties, exposed to different viewpoints, abandoned their more extreme positions – Republicans on immigration and Democrats on the economy. At the end, all but 5% agreed they “learned a lot about people very different from me – about what they and their lives are like.”

The cure to division, it turned out, was exposure.

There are elements of privilege involved in Ms. DeGeneres’ bonhomie with Mr. Bush, but that shouldn’t distract from research, like that of America in One Room, that shows spending time with people unlike you can create an overall good. Many have argued that the former president hasn’t apologized for what they see as past transgressions. But saying people are too far gone for our company suggests we don’t expect them to change in the first place.

Perhaps compassion and empathy, rather than ostracism, are better ways to change a mind. Maybe they can change what it means to be a “friend.”

At the start of World War II, Mahatma Gandhi wrote to Adolf Hitler, imploring him to end the fighting. At no point did he condone Hitler’s actions, calling them “monstrous and unbecoming of human dignity.” But that didn’t stop Gandhi from writing, separating evil acts from the person committing them. The letter never made it to Hitler, but if it had, he would have seen it addressed at the top: “Dear Friend.”


A Christian Science Perspective

About this feature

Each weekday, the Monitor includes one clearly labeled religious article offering spiritual insight on contemporary issues, including the news. The publication – in its various forms – is produced for anyone who cares about the progress of the human endeavor around the world and seeks news reported with compassion, intelligence, and an essentially constructive lens. For many, that caring has religious roots. For many, it does not. The Monitor has always embraced both audiences. The Monitor is owned by a church – The First Church of Christ, Scientist, in Boston – whose founder was concerned with both the state of the world and the quality of available news.

A story in today’s Daily highlights how traditional religious codes such as the Ten Commandments still make a difference in people’s lives. Here’s an article exploring the idea that glimpsing our spiritual origin as God’s children has a healing effect – physically, mentally, and morally.


A message of love

Rafael Marchante/Reuters
A woman takes cover Oct. 16, 2019, in Barcelona, Spain, as police officers walk past during a protest after a verdict in a trial over a banned Catalonia independence referendum. Unrest followed the conviction of nine separatist leaders on charges including sedition and misappropriation of funds. Catalonia’s regional president vowed to hold another referendum before the end of his term, according to The Washington Post. “No court,” he told the Post, “will prevent this president of Catalonia from continuing to open these debates.”
( The illustrations in today’s Monitor Daily are by Jacob Turcotte and Karen Norris. )

A look ahead

Thank you for coming to the Monitor today. Tomorrow, staff writer Ann Scott Tyson will share her thoughts on her recent trip to Hong Kong in a video photo essay, offering a unique look inside the struggle.

More issues

2019
October
17
Thursday

Give us your feedback

We want to hear, did we miss an angle we should have covered? Should we come back to this topic? Or just give us a rating for this story. We want to hear from you.