2019
October
15
Tuesday

Monitor Daily Podcast

October 15, 2019
Loading the player...

In today’s edition, our five hand-picked stories cover Turkey’s quest to protect itself, shifting political values in Ohio, censorship in Russia, the relevance of biblical morality today, and the mind-set of Gen Xers.

First, jokes about economics are legion: “Why was astrology invented? So economics would seem like an accurate science.”

But the winners of the 2019 Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences are changing that perception, one experiment at a time.

Abhijit Banerjee and Esther Duflo of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, and Michael Kremer of Harvard University won for “obtaining reliable answers about the best ways to fight global poverty.” Their work underscores a major shift in economics from ivory tower theories to street-level testing.

To help the poor, you have to start by jettisoning stereotypes. “Put away your preconceptions, and instead try and bring in a scientific and vigorous mindset. The key is to experiment,” Professor Duflo told the BBC. She is only the second woman to win the economics prize.

Big problems are broken into bite-sized questions. For example, if education is a path out of poverty, how do you get kids to stay in school? 

More schools? More teachers? Free school meals? Eliminate fees? Through a series of experiments in India and Africa, they found that simply telling parents about the benefits of education was 14 times more cost effective than free meals or hiring more teachers.

Over two decades, their approach of using randomized controlled trials has been applied to health care, microloans, gender equality, and crime reduction.

Economics is becoming a field that’s “humble, pragmatic, experimental and always tied to real people’s problems, especially those most in need,” writes Bloomberg columnist Noah Smith.


You've read  of  free articles. Subscribe to continue.

Today’s stories

And why we wrote them

Ugur Can/DHA/AP
Turkish forces advance toward the Kurdish-held town of Manbij, Syria, Oct.14, 2019. A U.S. military spokesman says U.S. forces have left Manbij as part of their withdrawal from northern Syria.

Despite new economic sanctions, Turkey isn’t likely to stop its military advance into Syria. As Ankara sees it, this is about self-preservation.

Ohio used to be a key swing state in presidential elections. But it's tilted red. Ahead of the latest TV debate, our reporter looks at why Democrats see an opening there. 

Alexei Druzhinin/Sputnik/Kremlin Photo/AP
In this undated photo released by the Russian Presidential Press Service, Russian President Vladimir Putin rests on a hill in Siberia during a hike ahead of his Oct. 7 birthday.

If you want to stop online criticism of a government official, will a punishment work? We look at Russia’s efforts to quell disrespect.

The Ten

How people use the Commandments in daily life
Karen Norris/Staff

We asked ordinary people of faith to share what “the Ten” mean to them personally to shed light on how 21st-century believers find meaning in ancient religious ideas. First in a series.

Mike Blake/Reuters
Former Rep. Beto O'Rourke (center) speaks as entrepreneur Andrew Yang (left) and former Housing Secretary Julian Castro listen during the 2020 Democratic presidential debate in Houston Sept. 12, 2019.

Gen Xers often have a distrust of politics. Our Gen X reporter looks at why this generation of Democratic presidential candidates isn’t finding much traction in the polls.


The Monitor's View

AP
Esther Duflo, left, and Abhijit Banerjee speak at a news conference at Massachusetts Institute of Technology in Cambridge, Mass., after being awarded the 2019 Nobel Prize in economics on Oct. 14.

Global poverty has been cut by more than half in the past couple of decades and one reason may be a new type of poverty-buster. A new branch of economics has radically changed views about poor people and what they are capable of. On Monday, three leaders in the field were honored with the 2019 Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences.

The three, Michael Kremer of Harvard University, and Esther Duflo and Abhijit Banerjee, both of Massachusetts Institute of Technology, have pioneered an experiment-based approach to ending poverty, doing real-world testing one microproject at a time rather than relying on the kind of big theories and statistical arguments found in traditional economics. 

Here’s how Dr. Duflo explains the approach: “It starts from the idea that the poor are often reduced to caricatures and even the people that try to help them do not actually understand what are the deep roots of [their] problems.”

“What we try to do in our approach is to say, ‘Look, let’s try to unpack the problems one-by-one and address them as rigorously and scientifically as possible’,” she added.

The premise is that poor people are already smart decision-makers who, with well-tested incentives to learn and earn, can lift themselves up. “A little bit of hope can allow people to realize their potential,” Dr. Duflo says.

Hope, of course, is not a strategy, as generals like to say. These economists and their followers have tested dozens of modest interventions to find out which ones work. Often the problem is not a lack of resources but a tailoring of assistance that emphasizes motivation and inspiration through example. Poor people are asked to offer perceptions of themselves or to identify the poorest among them.

Starting from these self-conceptions, various solutions are tested through “randomized control trials.” In India, for example, Dr. Banerjee tested ways to help low-performing students and found certain types of remedial tutoring brought the most progress. This individualized approach is now used for more than 5 million Indian children. In another project, researchers found farmers were more likely to adopt temporary subsidies for fertilizers rather than permanent assistance. In their eyes, the temporary aid better honored their sensibilities.

The researchers keep looking for the ultimate basis of hope. They know it rests on more than wishful thinking, new aspirations, or the freedom to define one’s future. One scholarly study cites hope as a “spiritual trust in God or other transcendental force.” Whatever the source, this new field, now aptly honored with a Nobel, is changing expectations about what poor people are able to do. The research has shown a resilience equal to the people it studies.


A Christian Science Perspective

About this feature

Each weekday, the Monitor includes one clearly labeled religious article offering spiritual insight on contemporary issues, including the news. The publication – in its various forms – is produced for anyone who cares about the progress of the human endeavor around the world and seeks news reported with compassion, intelligence, and an essentially constructive lens. For many, that caring has religious roots. For many, it does not. The Monitor has always embraced both audiences. The Monitor is owned by a church – The First Church of Christ, Scientist, in Boston – whose founder was concerned with both the state of the world and the quality of available news.

When a woman severely injured her toe during a weeklong hike, she found hope as well as healing in Jesus’ teaching about truth and freedom. Each of us can also find genuine healing by going deep with God’s inspiration. 


A message of love

Alvaro Barrientos/AP
A man places a Basque flag (left) and a Catalonian independence flag (right) near giant upside-down paintings of late Spanish dictator Francisco Franco (left) and Spanish King Felipe VI ahead of a protest in support of Catalonia's independence movement in Bilbao, Spain, on Oct. 15, 2019. Spain's Supreme Court on Monday sentenced nine prominent former Catalan politicians and activists for terms of nine to 13 years for illegally promoting the Catalonia region's independence. The ruling has spurred protests across Catalonia, and in particular at the airport in Barcelona, where dozens of flights have been canceled due to demonstrations there.
( The illustrations in today’s Monitor Daily are by Jacob Turcotte. )

A look ahead

Thanks for joining us. Come back tomorrow: We’re working on a story about California’s big fire-prevention blackout and why smaller solutions might be better.

More issues

2019
October
15
Tuesday

Give us your feedback

We want to hear, did we miss an angle we should have covered? Should we come back to this topic? Or just give us a rating for this story. We want to hear from you.