2017
July
07
Friday

Monitor Daily Podcast

July 07, 2017
Loading the player...
Clayton Collins
Director of Editorial Innovation

There’s an oddly enduring romanticism around the mano a mano.

The story that owned today’s news cycle pitted two presidents against each other in what one writer – an editor on gender issues – cast as cartoonish, the “ultimate man-off.” Everyone strained to assess the optics of the Trump-Putin meeting from ringside. CNN showed the handshake in sports-replay slow motion – over and over.

Would it be gladiatorial? A love fest? Might anything come of it? Election meddling reportedly was “raised.” In an encouraging development, it was announced that the United States, Russia, and Jordan had reached a cease-fire and agreed to “de-escalate” in southwestern Syria. 

Progress can be incremental, and quiet. On Thursday, before the Group of 20 got going, the European Union and Japan “agreed to the outlines” of a major trade deal of their own. (The EU struck one last fall with Canada.) The US will bluster about China but generally bows to mutual reliance. Even the so-called hermit kingdom of North Korea leans on a vast global network – some of it formal, much of it shadowy, reports The Wall Street Journal.

Over time, wins and losses proceed from the interplay of the deeply interdependent. Ultimately, of course, that’s all of us.

Now, to our five stories for today.


You've read  of  free articles. Subscribe to continue.

Today’s stories

And why we wrote them

While Syria and the ISIS fight may be overshadowed by North Korea just now, competing interests, spillover risk, and the human toll all factor in as the Pentagon prepares to release its new strategy. Will it exhibit a shift in thought?

Mariana Zuniga
A group of Venezuelan journalists belonging to an initiative called ‘El Bus TV’ read the news aboard a city bus in Caracas, Venezuela, June 29. The idea: Create a new type of live newscast to bring information directly to the people.

In the midst of unrelenting political turmoil, and the social media rumor storm it has spawned, journalists are finding novel and creative ways of overcoming misinformation.

Another story about media doing its job: Al Jazeera has faced pressure from conservative Gulf regimes over its airing of different social views. It’s also based in and funded by Qatar. That has made it an even bigger target in a current regional spat.

When “self-parking” cars emerged a decade ago, I was among the skeptical writers bothering city drivers with snail-paced experimentation. With fuller automotive autonomy, the issues have become far more complex. They extend now to morality. 

Courtesy of Christoph Gerigk/Damien Hirst and Science Ltd
The installment 'Hydra and Kali Discovered by Four Divers' is part of a new Damien Hirst exhibition in Venice called 'Treasures from the Wreck Unbelievable.'

You may know the British artist Damien Hirst for his work in expired sheep and formaldehyde. In 2015, The Guardian called him “an agent of change” whose qualities and artistic practices “challenge ideas about authenticity.” His new work seems to deliver on that.


The Monitor's View

Eric Gay/AP
Sen. Ted Cruz (R) of Texas debates with Gary Marsh over health care during a town hall meeting Thursday in Austin, Texas.

Louisiana’s Republican Sen. Bill Cassidy kicked off the July 4 recess with a town hall in Baton Rouge that, at times, veered into confrontation over the GOP health-care bill that’s now stalled in the Senate.  

The congenial senator, a physician, tried to dissipate chants and interruptions by reminding folks to be “civil.” A constituent shot back: “I’m civil. I don’t think it’s civil to kill people,” according to a report by The Hill newspaper.

There’s nothing quite as personal as health care to arouse the passions of voters. In the summer of 2009, angry tea party protesters swarmed town halls of Democrats working on health-care legislation. Now the tables are turned – to the point where some Republicans are simply not holding these meetings with the public, or finding a way to screen questions or restrict access.

Town halls are an American democratic tradition, a quintessential way for constituents to be heard by and to hear from their representatives. It’s possible to keep the passion, but turn down the heat so that these valuable face-to-face meetings can flourish.

Both lawmakers and constituents have legitimate concerns when hot-button issues like health care generate public pandemonium. 

The shooting of Rep. Steve Scalise (R) of Louisiana and others at a GOP charity baseball practice last month shook up members of Congress, who voiced concern about security at public gatherings, including town halls. That’s in addition to being shouted down while trying to answer questions.

But many constituents, too, are frightened – genuinely worried about losing health coverage. They are organizing precisely because of their concerns, exercising their right to voice their views. 

Meanwhile, those who might support their lawmaker or the GOP legislation feel as if they’re being squelched as organized opponents dominate town halls.

Both constituents and politicians need to adjust to make town halls more productive. 

The guide to town halls offered by the grass-roots group Indivisible, which is organizing against the GOP health-carelegislation, urges folks to “be polite” and “look friendly or neutral.” Norms that govern conversation outside town halls ought to be just as valid inside them. 

While some lawmakers are turning to telephone town halls or registering people, they need to consider the kinds of restrictions they use. 

Town halls are actually not a common tool for senators, many of whom have vast distances to cover and have other ways of interacting with constituents. A telephone town hall may be a more effective way for them to reach large numbers of people – but that can also frustrate citizens, especially if it’s clear that questions are being screened.

Similarly, representatives might register people at in-person town halls in order to make sure that they are actual constituents. But blocking them by other criteria or simply limiting them invites a backlash.

“In the tradition of town halls, we should not control the numbers but use public spaces that will accommodate the level of interest and the level of passion,” says Carolyn Lukensmeyer, executive director of the National Institute for Civil Discourse in Washington. 

At times like these, that argues for school auditoriums over cramped function rooms.

Ms. Lukensmeyer suggests that town halls be moderated by respected community figures so that all voices are heard, including the lawmaker’s. 

And she puts forward this radical idea: Republicans and Democrats who serve on the same committee should do town halls in each other’s districts so that they get a different perspective on issues. Rep. Elijah Cummings (D) of Maryland and Rep. Jason Chaffetz (R) of Utah actually did that in 2014. 

Town halls are central to American democracy. Let the voices be heard – all of them.


A Christian Science Perspective

About this feature

Each weekday, the Monitor includes one clearly labeled religious article offering spiritual insight on contemporary issues, including the news. The publication – in its various forms – is produced for anyone who cares about the progress of the human endeavor around the world and seeks news reported with compassion, intelligence, and an essentially constructive lens. For many, that caring has religious roots. For many, it does not. The Monitor has always embraced both audiences. The Monitor is owned by a church – The First Church of Christ, Scientist, in Boston – whose founder was concerned with both the state of the world and the quality of available news.

When contributor Susan Kerr saw the tall ships from the Rendez-Vous 2017 Tall Ships Regatta sail into Boston Harbor earlier this month, it really got her thinking. Not just about the fascinating history of the ships, but about some of the qualities they and their journeys represented – such as strength, precision, and persistence. Such qualities are inherent in each of us, too, because we are the reflection of God, divine Mind. Life isn’t always smooth sailing, but striving to better understand God’s creation (including all of us) as being good and reflecting divine intelligence helps us over waves of discouragement or fear. “You rule the raging of the sea,” the Bible says of God, “when its waves rise, You still them” (Psalms 89:9, New King James Version).


A message of love

Christophe Ena/AP
Two girls watched cyclists line up today for the start of the seventh stage of the Tour de France, which covers more than 130 miles between Troyes and Nuits-Saint-Georges, France. The final stage concludes July 23 in Paris. You can follow the race at http://www.letour.fr/us/.
( The illustrations in today’s Monitor Daily are by Jacob Turcotte. )

A look ahead

Thanks for joining us today and all week. We’re still sifting for next week’s lineups. But watch for a story on how investment in a seed bank for corals could provide insurance for the world's imperiled reefs. 

Stepping into some warm garden soil this weekend? I recommend going barefoot – also this piece about how community gardening became an act of love by a “city girl” who wanted the neighborhood kids to know that peas didn’t originate in the grocery store. 

More issues

2017
July
07
Friday

Give us your feedback

We want to hear, did we miss an angle we should have covered? Should we come back to this topic? Or just give us a rating for this story. We want to hear from you.